Auction comparison
Online vs in-lane dealer auctions
How buying in the lane compares with buying online, from the published rules of the major auction groups. An in-lane sale is a live auction at a physical site: the car drives through the lane and an auctioneer takes bids.
About this comparison
Published by AutoVue. AutoVue does not run auctions. Every fact below links to the company's own public page or filing. Sources checked November 17, 2026.
AutoVue's stocking software gives used-car dealers a daily stocking plan built from their market and their own sales, with target buy prices for every car.
What the terms mean
An in-lane sale is a live auction at a physical site: the car drives through the lane and an auctioneer takes bids. Manheim describes in-lane and Simulcast sales as live, auctioneer-led events where the time to decide is short.[1]
An online auction is a digital marketplace where licensed dealers buy wholesale vehicles without attending a physical auction.[13]
Side by side
| In-lane | Online | |
|---|---|---|
| How you bid | Live, with an auctioneer, in the lane at the auction.[1] | Live from a screen (Simulcast), or in timed sales, 20-minute auctions, Buy Now and offers.[2][3] |
| Time to decide | Short: the car is on the block for a live sale.[1] | Simulcast is live, like the lane.[1] Timed sales on Manheim.com run 24/7.[2] |
| Seeing the car | You can see the car at the sale. | You rely on the condition report: for example engine audio and undercarriage views at ACV,[4] OBDII scans at ADESA Clear,[5] 25+ photos at OPENLANE.[6] |
| Arbitration window | At Manheim: file by close of business on sale day.[7] At ADESA: the NAAA Appendix I periods.[8] | At Manheim and ADESA: 10 calendar days for digital purchases.[7][8] |
| Access | AuctionACCESS credentials cover over 400 marketplaces and online channels, but each auction still needs its own registration.[9] | Same credentials. At ADESA, online buying is usually approved within five business days.[10] |
| Getting the car home | Arrange pick-up or transport from the auction. | Transport is offered at checkout at several marketplaces, such as ACV[11] and OPENLANE.[12] |
AutoVue · for dealers
Got a run list? Get a max bid on every car before the sale.
AutoVue ranks auction vehicles by demand in your local market, so you only bid on cars that will turn.
30-min demo for dealers
Which fits your store?
Buy in-lane if…
- you want to see and hear the car before you bid;
- you are near a physical auction and can attend on sale day.
Buy online if…
- you buy from more auctions than you can drive to;
- you trust detailed condition reports and want more time to file arbitration (at Manheim, 10 days online against sale day in-lane).
AuctionACCESS membership costs $107 a year per credentialed individual, plus sales tax.[9]
More comparisons
Sources
- New Dealer: Buyer FAQ site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html
- Manheim Digital Buyer Protection site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/digital-buyer-protection.html
- ACV - Support - Understanding Auction Types acvauctions.com/support-article/understanding-auction-types
- Support | ACV Auctions acvauctions.com/support
- ADESA - Clear adesa.com/clear/
- Buy Wholesale Used Cars Online | Dealer Marketplace | OPENLANE openlane.com/buyers/
- Arbitration Process Timelines/Deadlines site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/arbitration-process-timelines.html
- ADESA Arbitration Guidelines - Adesa Help help.adesa.com/knowledge-base/adesa-arbitration-guidelines/
- FAQs - AuctionACCESS auctionaccess.com/faqs/index.html
- ADESA - Get Started adesa.com/get-started/
- Online Car Auctions for Used Cars, Trucks & SUVs | ACV Auctions acvauctions.com/
- Top 10 FAQs About Buying Wholesale on OPENLANE | OPENLANE openlane.com/insights/top-10-faqs-about-buying-wholesale-on-openlane/
- Find Used Car Auctions For Dealers | OPENLANE openlane.com/online-auctions/
Sources checked November 17, 2026. Companies change their terms; check the source before you rely on a detail.