Auction comparison
Manheim vs ADESA vs ACV vs America's Auto Auction
How four dealer auction groups compare on ownership, locations, sale formats, buyer access, fees, arbitration and services. Pick Manheim if you want the choice of in-lane, Simulcast or 24/7 digital buying at one group. Pick ADESA if you buy at ADESA locations or want timed digital sales where the starting bid is the reserve (ADESA Clear).
About this comparison
Published by AutoVue. AutoVue does not run auctions. Every fact below links to the company's own public page or filing. Sources checked November 17, 2026.
AutoVue's stocking software gives used-car dealers a daily stocking plan built from their market and their own sales, with target buy prices for every car.
Side by side
| Manheim | ADESA | ACV | America's Auto Auction | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner | A Cox Automotive brand, established in 1945.[1] Cox Automotive is a subsidiary of privately owned Cox Enterprises.[2] | ADESA's U.S. physical auctions were sold to Carvana in May 2022.[3] KAR Global (now OPENLANE) kept ADESA Canada, U.K. and Europe.[3] | A Copart subsidiary since October 16, 2026, when Copart completed its acquisition.[4] | American Auto Auction Group, LLC, doing business as America's Auto Auction.[5] It describes itself as privately held.[6] |
| Locations (as published) | "80+ locations" on its about page;[1] "over 100 locations worldwide" on its locations page.[7] | Carvana's annual report says the 2022 deal added 56 locations.[8] adesa.com publishes no current total. | Not published as a count. ACV describes "a growing network of physical hubs".[9] | "More than 55 auction locations across North America" (November 2026).[6] |
| Listed on The Run List | 71 locations | 31 locations | 1 location | 13 locations |
| Sale formats | Live sales in-lane or through Simulcast;[10] OVE listings with Buy Now, a starting bid or Make an Offer;[10] timed sales on Manheim.com, 24/7.[11] | In-lane and Simulcast, plus ADESA Clear, DealerBlock and ADESA Timed Sales online.[12] In ADESA Clear the starting bid equals the reserve.[13] | 20-minute online auctions with a seller-set reserve;[14] other types include Buy Now and Make Offer;[14] on-site auctions at some sites.[9] | Live in-lane and online sales, Edge Simulcast, mobile sales and America's Digital (24/7).[15] |
| Who can buy | Dealers, verified with an Auction Access ID;[16] some locations also hold public auctions.[7] | Registered dealers with an AuctionACCESS number; non-dealers are pointed to public auctions.[17] | Members with a dealer license;[18] AuctionACCESS is used to verify credentials.[19] | Dealer-only wholesale auctions;[20] AuctionACCESS registration;[5] GSA/public sales at some locations.[21] |
| Buyer fees | No U.S. buyer fee schedule on the pages we checked.[10] A late-payment policy is published: 3% after business day 3, $40 minimum, $400 maximum, at Manheim facilitating auctions.[22] | Shown on each vehicle's page ("Buy Fees" button) before you bid.[23] | In the MyACV fee schedule for members; fees vary by tier.[24] | No national fee schedule published.[25] |
| Arbitration window | In-lane: file by close of business on sale day. Simulcast and Timed (OVE): 10 calendar days from the sale.[26] | ADESA Clear, Timed and Simulcast: 10 calendar days. In-lane: NAAA Appendix I periods.[12] Optional ADESA Assurance: 21-day return, $195 base price per vehicle.[27] | 10 calendar days from purchase; buyers can buy 10 extra days.[28] | Follows NAAA policies and each location's policy; no single national window is published.[25] |
| Condition reports | Reports can carry a grade from a trained inspector;[10] paid options include Purchase Protection and post-sale inspections.[10] | ADESA Clear reports include OBDII scans; post-sale inspections are offered.[29] | Engine audio (AMP), undercarriage views, an OBDII scan, a paint meter and a basic Carfax report.[18] | Condition reports and pre- and post-sale inspections; availability varies by location.[30] |
| Transport | Central Dispatch or Ready Logistics at checkout.[31] | Listed among dealer services.[17] | ACV Transportation, a network of over 5,000 carriers.[32] | Local transportation; availability varies by location.[33] |
| Floorplan | NextGear Capital.[34] | No named partner published; ADESA Clear accepts floor plan payments.[23] | ACV Capital; most major floor plans also accepted.[32] | No named partner published.[5] |
"Listed on The Run List" counts the locations in our own directory whose name starts with the group's name. It is not the company's own count.
ADESA and OPENLANE are not the same company in the U.S.
KAR Global sold ADESA's U.S. physical auctions to Carvana in 2022[3] and renamed itself OPENLANE in 2023.[35] OPENLANE runs a digital dealer marketplace with live auctions on Mondays and Thursdays and Buy it Now.[36]
AutoVue · for dealers
Got a run list? Get a max bid on every car before the sale.
AutoVue ranks auction vehicles by demand in your local market, so you only bid on cars that will turn.
30-min demo for dealers
Which one fits your store?
Pick Manheim if…
- you want the choice of in-lane, Simulcast or 24/7 digital buying at one group;
- you finance with NextGear Capital, Manheim's floor plan partner.
Pick ADESA if…
- you buy at ADESA locations or want timed digital sales where the starting bid is the reserve (ADESA Clear);
- you want a paid 21-day return option (ADESA Assurance).
Pick ACV if…
- you like fast online auctions (20 minutes) with detailed digital condition reports;
- you want transport and ACV Capital financing at checkout.
Pick America's Auto Auction if…
- you buy in-lane in its regions and also want Edge Simulcast or 24/7 digital sales;
- you check each location's own arbitration and fee policies.
Every group asks for dealer credentials, and three of the four use AuctionACCESS.[37] For a checklist before your first sale, see how to buy at dealer auctions.
More comparisons
Sources
- About Manheim site.manheim.com/en/about-manheim.html
- About Us | Cox Automotive coxautoinc.com/about-us/
- KAR Global Completes Sale of ADESA US Physical Auction Business to Carvana | OPENLANE corporate.openlane.com/kar-global-completes-sale-of-adesa-us-physical-auction-business-to-
- Copart Completes Acquisition of ACV (Copart Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1) sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000900075/000119312526423478/d129535dex991.htm
- America's Auto Auction Terms and Conditions (Effective June 1, 2026) americasaa.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/AAA-Terms-and-Conditions-Revised-6.1.2026.pdf
- America's Auto Auction Acquires Vemo Auto Auctions americasaa.com/news/americas-auto-auction-expands-florida-presence-with-acquisition-of-vem
- Manheim Locations site.manheim.com/en/locations.html
- Carvana Co. Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025 (cvna-20251231) sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1690820/000169082026000009/cvna-20251231.htm
- ACV Remarketing Centers | Reconditioning Services for Dealers acvauctions.com/remarketing-centers
- New Dealer: Buyer FAQ site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration/new-dealer-buyer.html
- Manheim Digital Buyer Protection site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/digital-buyer-protection.html
- ADESA Arbitration Guidelines - Adesa Help help.adesa.com/knowledge-base/adesa-arbitration-guidelines/
- ADESA adesa.com/
- ACV - Support - Understanding Auction Types acvauctions.com/support-article/understanding-auction-types
- America's Digital Services | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/digital-services/
- New Dealer Account Sign-Up/Management FAQ site.manheim.com/en/help/new-dealer-registration.html
- ADESA - Get Started adesa.com/get-started/
- Support | ACV Auctions acvauctions.com/support
- ACV Auctions Now Using AuctionACCESS for Credential Verification | ACV Auctions acvauctions.com/blog/auctionaccess-for-acv
- Wholesale Auto Auctions | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/wholesale-dealer-auto-auctions/
- GSA / Public Auto Auctions | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/gsa-public-auto-auctions/
- Late Payment Policy site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/purchase-terms-overview.html
- Buyer FAQs - Adesa Help help.adesa.com/knowledge-base/adesa-clear-faqs/
- ACV - Support - Understanding Buyer Fees acvauctions.com/support-article/understanding-buyer-fees
- Forms & Policies | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/policies/
- Arbitration Process Timelines/Deadlines site.manheim.com/en/marketplace-policies/us-policies/arbitration-process-timelines.html
- ADESA - Assurance adesa.com/assurance/
- Vehicle Condition Arbitration Policy | ACV Auction acvauctions.com/legal/arbitration
- ADESA - Clear adesa.com/clear/
- Pre-Sale Services | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/pre-sale-services/
- Logistics site.manheim.com/solutions/logistics
- Online Car Auctions for Used Cars, Trucks & SUVs | ACV Auctions acvauctions.com/
- Post-Sale Services | America's Auto Auction americasaa.com/post-sale-services/
- Financing site.manheim.com/en/services/financing.html
- KAR Global to Rebrand as OPENLANE corporate.openlane.com/kar-global-to-rebrand-as-openlane/
- Buy Wholesale Used Cars Online | Dealer Marketplace | OPENLANE openlane.com/buyers/
- FAQs - AuctionACCESS auctionaccess.com/faqs/index.html
Sources checked November 17, 2026. Companies change their terms; check the source before you rely on a detail.